Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.

Share this post

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
About the book 'Measure What Matters'...
User's avatar
Discover more from Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
A resource for tech leaders: Be a more helpful leader by giving teams the context they need to do their best work: practical advice and proven practices for CTOs by an experienced CTO and CTO Coach.
Already have an account? Sign in
Focus with goals (OKR etc.)

About the book 'Measure What Matters'...

For a long time, I have been critical of the book. After a recent second reading, I have softened. Here's why.

Daniel Walters's avatar
Daniel Walters
Sep 18, 2023
5

Share this post

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
About the book 'Measure What Matters'...
Share

red and white boat on sea under gray sky
Photo by Amirhossein Khedri on Unsplash

Measure What Matters introduced Objectives and Key Results (OKRs) to the masses and should be lauded for this contribution. On the other hand, it also provides many examples of OKR practices that have since proven less effective than alternatives. The book’s popularity, combined with the assumption by many readers it is a ‘how-to’ guide, has led many astray when they follow examples from the book too closely. Thus to vilify or revere the book, it's a tricky question.

Not all approaches to OKRs are the same (and some are better than others)

I became critical of the Measure What Matters book once I formed the opinion that Objectives should reflect Outcomes and not Outputs or Actions. This was a conclusion I reached after a significant period of working with our teams using OKRs and some inspired suggestions from some clever colleagues. I also experienced first-hand the benefits of aligning OKRs over cascading them.

Focus on outcomes is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

I have softened my view on my second reading of the book much more recently. Not on the aforementioned principles but I am more sympathetic to the book's place in history and it's approach. Measure What Matters served a purpose, and the credibility and authority of its author, John Doerr, helped build the awareness of OKRs to where it is today.

The book's structure was mainly around how several well-known organisations were using OKRs, which influenced many of the examples. Given its popularity, it seems in part that structure resonated. People respond to learning what other successful organisations use.

As a 'how to', that structure is less helpful unless you carefully consider the book in this context. By this, what I mean is that you must look at each example to reflect where those organisations were in their journey at the time and not necessarily as examples of ‘best practice’. Personally, I've been more influenced by the writing of Wodtke, Castro, Cutler, Barr, McCarthy and others when it comes to the leading edge of OKR best practices.

The ease of implementing OKRs is impacted by the number of bad examples available for reference. I believe the volume of bad examples is partially a function of OKR tool companies and the content they produce as much as any other source. They may have been influenced by content in Measure What Matters, but they are mostly influenced by the vast majority of users of their tools who are looking for an easy path to ‘doing OKRs’ which, as I cover in the following post, is a decent indicator you aren’t up for the commitment needed to focus on outcomes:

Don't start your OKR journey with an OKR tool

Don't start your OKR journey with an OKR tool

Daniel Walters
·
June 29, 2022
Read full story

The evolution in books on OKRs is a shift to addressing the practical concerns of implementation. For instance, Allan Kelly’s book ‘Succeeding With OKRs in Agile’ focuses on how OKRs are used with agile practices. The topic is focused and practical and addresses many questions about getting the most out of OKRs in their context.

I think it’s fair that some clear disclaimers be public and at suitable levels of awareness regarding the strengths and weaknesses of Measure What Matters fitness as a guide for implementing OKRs. But if it's a choice between criticising a work that helped bring awareness to a helpful approach to goal-setting or sharing what we have learned about using OKRs successfully, I choose the latter.

Suppose we want the awareness of what practices work best in each situation. In that case, we must put more, higher quality examples into the public domain and show the value of these more disciplined approaches.

Share

Where do you stand on Measure What Matters? Please share your view in the comments.

Leave a comment

Focus on outcomes is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Billy Robins's avatar
Daniel Walters's avatar
5 Likes
5

Share this post

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
About the book 'Measure What Matters'...
Share

Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Improving OKRs
There's a number of common ways leading practitioners of OKRs improve upon the most common form of OKRs
Apr 20, 2023 â€¢ 
Daniel Walters
7

Share this post

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Improving OKRs
How leaders should invest their time: Walters' Lever of Improvement
All things being equal, where can leaders exert their effort and have the most significant impact? Here's a simple model I call Walters' Lever of…
Aug 1, 2022 â€¢ 
Daniel Walters
5

Share this post

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
How leaders should invest their time: Walters' Lever of Improvement
A CTO's Guide to Time Management
To be strategic, CTOs need blocks of time available for deep thinking and collaboration to maintain a standard they hold themselves to. Here's how to…
Oct 24, 2024 â€¢ 
Daniel Walters
4

Share this post

Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
Great CTO - Dedicated to helping CTOs thrive.
A CTO's Guide to Time Management

Ready for more?

© 2025 Daniel Walters
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share

Create your profile

User's avatar

Only paid subscribers can comment on this post

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in

Check your email

For your security, we need to re-authenticate you.

Click the link we sent to , or click here to sign in.